Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
14 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
ThomasJNewton
2 years ago

Helium is not able to absorb or emit thermal radiation (far infrared). As well as the main components nitrogen and oxygen.
This has nothing to do with chemical behavior.

ThomasJNewton
2 years ago
Reply to  sauidha4ssa3

There must be molecular vibrations in which the dipole moment changes. In the case of CO2, there are 2 such vibrations when the carbon atom oscillates along the binding axis opposite to the O atoms and when the carbon atom oscillates transversely to the binding axis. N2 and O2 do not have a dipole moment and can not get any if the atomic distance changes. Helium does not even form molecules.
The greenhouse effect is based on the fact that the sunlight (mainly near IR and visible light) penetrates unhindered through, but the removal of the earth (distance IR) is absorbed.

YBCO123
1 year ago

Because it is a noble gas and therefore no molecular vibrations can be excited 🙂

anwesende
1 year ago

In order for a molecule to be effective in the climate, it must have a polarized bond, i.e. consist of at least 2 different atoms.

It is complicated by the fact that the molecule as a whole does not have to be a dipole. Main thing, 2 atoms with different EN.

All noble gases fall from your list because no 2 atoms in the molecule, and all elements (O2, N2) because no 2 different atoms.

m.f.G.

present

FabianPavian
1 year ago
Reply to  anwesende

You have well explained the necessary condition for a gas molecule to act as a greenhouse gas. However, other molecules than greenhouse gases can also be “climate-effective”. For example, argon also ensures heating to a small extent because it reduces the thermal conductivity of the atmosphere due to its large mass. As a result, heat is transported from the warm ground to the cold heights. And O2 and N2 are slightly cooling because they scatter a small part of the sunlight back into the orbit.

ThomasJNewton
1 year ago
Reply to  FabianPavian

Nonsense. Do you always have to add your must when it comes to climate without any consideration?

Littlethought
2 years ago

Helium practically does not occur in the atmosphere of the earth. This is why it was only discovered by the absorption strips in the sunlight and therefore also bears the name of the sun god Helios. In addition, it is a noble gas and reacts practically not to radiation with sunlight, which we have here on Earth.

Remmelken
2 years ago

Helium is not a climate gas because when it first reaches the atmosphere it simply rises higher and higher until it disappears in space. It is also chemical inside, it does not react with other substances.

Kerner
2 years ago

Hello,

because it is completely low-reaction.

As long as it is not in a fusion reactor.

Hansi

FabianPavian
1 year ago

Helium has a weak cooling effect because it increases the thermal conductivity of the air due to its low weight (and consequently high speed). As a result, heat is better transported from the warm ground to the cold heights (and to radiation). In this respect, helium is actually a slightly cooling climate gas. But it’s not a greenhouse gas.

The oscillation of a molecule can absorb heat radiation only when the dipole moment of the molecule changes during the oscillation. Since helium does not form bindings, there can be no vibration in trivial manner and there can also be no vibration at which its dipole moment changes.

Also in the case of 2-atomic molecules such as N2, O2, H2, Cl2 … which consist of two identical atoms, there can be no vibration that can absorb IR light (and re-emitulate). It looks different from NO and CO. These are actually weak greenhouse gases.

But the greenhouse gasses are just starting with 3-atomy gases. There are so-called bending vibrations. This is an oscillation in which the binding does not submerge or expands, but displaced. You’ve got a strong feather fixed at one end. It is much easier to push the other end a little to the side than to press the spring together. This is also the case with the bending vibrations. These absorb very easily heat radiation.

CO2 is, by the way, a special case because of its linearity in the basic state. As a result, it not only reproduces radiation of the frequency which it previously absorbed, but also in smaller frequencies, and this preferably directed into the same direction, into which previously absorbed IR photon was directed. And its IR-active vibrations can also be excited by collision with other gas molecules. Unfortunately, the whole situation is much more complicated than the mainstream of climate research wants to make us believe.

DerBayer80
2 years ago

Because helium does not in any way effect a greenhouse effect. In addition, about 1/4 of the total mass of the universe consists of helium

hologence
2 years ago

Complaints must be submitted to the Ministry of Chemistry.

BenjaminSisko
1 year ago

Because molecules of at least three atoms are needed.