Where does the period go in a direct quote?

According to him, "that's a dog."

According to him, "that's a dog."

I know this is really trivial, but I can't find anything about it online. Sometimes the period is placed within the quote, sometimes it isn't. I'm currently writing my first term paper and really need to know this. Could someone please help me?

(2 votes)
Loading...

Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
7 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Thelice
10 months ago

According to him, it’s a dog.

In this example, I am absolutely sure.

If it is for university or other higher schools, there are usually citation rules where you can find out exactly what form the source directory is expected. This can actually vary from subject to subject, apply the same rules for all subjects, you will find on the hps of the disciplines meiat a link to a complete list of how to cite.

Whether schools have to do this, I do not know, but is quite possible.

In general, the following applies in German:

In literal speeches, a point (which marks the end of the said sentence) is omitted or comes after the goose feet. ABER ONLY if the sentence stops after that. If the remaining limb or even more comes after the geese feet, you simply leave the point. Call sign + question mark IMMER VOR den Gänsefüsschen.

I am about 75% sure that these rules also apply if there is no literal speech but a quote (from a source or a celebrity).

Basically, this is also a quote, “we usually don’t call that,” Anna said.

The President said, “It should be clear with this.”

A quotation could be: “Everyone is responsible for everything, and everyone knows that, we wouldn’t have a problem.”

The quote: “Luke, I am your father” doesn’t seem literally in the movie Star Wars.

Within the quotation, i.e. within your geese, the phrases must not be changed.

I hope that will help you succeed in your work! She will be super 😉

Thelice
10 months ago
Reply to  Thelice

Aja, in your example, you can express with the word “sei” instead of “is” that you do not know the truth content of the statement. More neutral..

HawkeyeDZoro
10 months ago

The phrases and the quotation marks come where the quotation also stood. Is that a dog is primarily a question and therefore there is no question mark.

“Is that a dog?”

If, however, it was quoted as in

Is that a dog and what breed does your dog have?

It is quoted in the following.

“Is that a dog […] what breed does your dog have?”

These […] in quotes you can see again and again with journalistic contributions in which something irrelevant is released from quotes as in this case the word and. However, one should check the missing passages at […] critical contributions, as often relevant things are omitted, just to change statements in favor of a contribution.

Koschutnig
10 months ago

You can find information in this respect at any rate with the producers of our spelling, the German legislative council. Its rules are here, for quotation and point see §§ 89 f.

https://www.rechtschreibrat.pdf

WilliamDeWorde
10 months ago

There is no sentence, there is no point.

In contrast, a sentence is: according to him, “is that a dog.” <- Point

Thelice
10 months ago
Reply to  WilliamDeWorde

But “this is a dog” is a sentence. This does not change, even if you match the word position to quote with the rest.

WilliamDeWorde
10 months ago
Reply to  Thelice

“This is a dog” is not a sentence. One sentence would be: “This is a dog.”

Otherwise, this sentence is nowhere. I don’t understand what you want to explain to me at all.