Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
12 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Koschutnig
1 year ago

That should be a mistake.

However, there is also the form “welcher” in a neutrum, namely that of the genitive in the plural (equal to all 3 genera m/f/n of course) and means “of which” or “of which”;

N pl – which

G pl – which

D pl.

A pl.

For example, you can ask:

With the results the these products were you satisfied?

spanferkel14
1 year ago

Your question set is grammatically wrong, because the verb needs an object in the battery. The question is: Who or what have you tried before?

  1. Food and beverages: try + battery
  2. Equipment/machines/instruments: try out / test + battery
  3. Clothing/clothes: to try + battery

Accurate

  • m. the car: Welchen have you tried this car before?en here. / The there. / Noen (of which).
  • n. product: Welchit have you tried these products before? –
  • Thisit here. / The there. / NoS (of which).
  • f. the cake: Welche have you ever tried this freezer?e here. / The there. / Noe (of which).
  • Plur. the shoes: Welche have you ever tried these shoes? – Thise here. / The there. / Noe (of which).
indiachinacook
1 year ago

Which of these products have you tried?

This sentence is incorrect — the interrogative pronoun must be in the battery here, namely the object of the sentence (who or what do you try?). Without a further context, I recommend the Akk Sg thebut Akk Pl the is also possible.

The word group these products form a genitivattribute to the subject; it is partitative to understand, so in the sense of of all these products.

If you do not want to question the sentence, but to formulate it clearly, then you must replace the interrogative pronoun with something else according to the desired meaning, e.g.

Many/a few of these products have already been tested.

I’ve tried none of these products before.

As written, these sentences are possible if one wishes to emphasise the first word in particular; In most cases, however, one would pack the object behind the verb and put the subject in the first place:

I have tried many/a few of these products once.

I didn’t try any of these products once.

This position sounds more neutral.

66trixie66
1 year ago

Which of these products you have tried

is grammatically wrong.
It means either “what these products” (if you are a Select product from a list) or “what of these products” if you choose several Select products from a list).

Which is rechargeable Singular, which is rechargeable plural. (Who or what have you ever used?

MaxMusterman353
1 year ago

The = Which / This

The = Which / This

The = Which / This

MaxMusterman353
1 year ago
Reply to  kingafghan

Product = Which / This product

Products = Which / These products

Did I get it right?

MaxMusterman353
1 year ago

Right. “What these products” or “what these products”. “This” is correct (Genitivattribute).

66trixie66
1 year ago

“Welcher” is definitely wrong.

Glueckwunsch49
1 year ago

Product is causal, so which of these products.

I know this product.

I often buy these products.