Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
37 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
wunschname0302
1 year ago

We have “just” a well-tempered (uniformly tuned) piano. In so far as I don’t care because I don’t think there are atmospheric mood differences. But there are some interesting pieces with many “signs”. :

wunschname0302
1 year ago

This is a very good argument. Depending on the progress/beginner, you feel rather carefully along the quint circle, so first of all is the C major and then G major, D major… At the middle level, it is probably no matter, or possibly at the piano even partially pleasant to use the famous black keys. Just think about Schubert-Impromptus or Beethoven piano sonatas.

wunschname0302
1 year ago

PS: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxhbAGwEYGQ

(unembedded in the comment – it is a Schubert-Impromptu in Ges-Dur von Horowitz)

Bluemilk
1 year ago

What do you mean? What pitch (Kammerton a1) do you want to refer to? On the piano or keyboard, the tones are tuned in the same-stage or in the same-floor condition, as a result, any tonal characteristic that would have been in a so-called historical (unequal-weaving) mood is eliminated, but one should be clear about what mood one refers to. Such historical moods would be, for example, work masters (there are several), Kirnberger (there are several), Young, Schlick, Valotti, Neydhardt, medium-tone etc. etc.

There is the so-called natural tone series, this is physics, and the whole music builds on it. All assignments of any characteristics of sound are irrelevant. If one moves within a non-uniformly heated mood through the tones, some tones will be purer, others will be less pure. Cleaner tones are more beautiful for most people, more impurely less beautiful, perhaps also dramatic, as you just want.

Such assignments also have no meaning. True heights were very different in the course of music history. For example, A Dur sounds just like Gis Dur at a true height of a1 =415 Hz, and so on, and so on…

joerosac
1 year ago

Quite simply for the reason that I almost only play Ukulele and that is g-C-E-A tuned, there is one finger on the third covenant of the A string and the C major chord is finished. Where – it actually plays almost everything by itself… Click… 😝

Wotquenne
11 months ago

For me it is clear It major! That’s my heart. I love this breadth, majestic, voluminous, triumphant. A few examples?

  1. Mozart: Ouvertüren zur »Zauberflöte« KV 620
  2. Mozart: Symphony No. 39 KV 543
  3. Mozart: Piano Concerto No. 22 KV 482
  4. Beethoven: Symphony No. 3 op. 55 (»Eroica«)
  5. Beethoven: Piano Concerto No. 5 op. 73 (»Emperor«, »Kaiserkonzert«)
TheDutchOven
11 months ago

On the Cdur and amoll keyboard.

On guitar Edur and emoll.

In the end, however, it doesn’t matter because you usually depend on the singer anyway.

allocigar78
1 year ago

B major and at the same time I do not mean the German H Dur but Bb.

Muktamani
1 year ago

Brilliant, magnificent sound, fresh, active and cheerful.

Muktamani
1 year ago

Sure.

TheDutchOven
11 months ago
Reply to  Muktamani

In the well-tempered mood there are no different key characteristics that Edur makes brilliant, better and fresher as well as more cheerful than, for example, Gdur sound.

Muktamani
11 months ago
Reply to  TheDutchOven

These are just individual sensations.

And the Bohemian brass music gets its characteristic sound also because it usually sounds in b tons. I can’t wipe it like that.

Physically, this may be so explainable, but there is something else in it.

Muktamani
11 months ago

If I don’t understand it, Schwarzenegger applies:

“I’ll be back…”.

Muktamani
11 months ago

You have to explain. That would be new to me.

OK, I’ll look around myself.

TheDutchOven
11 months ago

Blasinstruments are also not arrested in the well-tempered mood. On the well-tempered piano, that’s different.

Geophage
1 year ago

Lydical.

tommgrinn
1 year ago

Moll is better:)

TheDutchOven
11 months ago
Reply to  tommgrinn

In general, you can’t let that stand. You like moll. I like mixedolydic. I don’t see better and worse. . .

tommgrinn
11 months ago
Reply to  TheDutchOven

In general, you can’t let that stand.

When can you argue about taste?

tommgrinn
11 months ago

I see I stayed in your heart. Your pulse is quite excited to read from me. In the long run, maybe not healthy for you.

TheDutchOven
11 months ago

F.U.

tommgrinn
11 months ago

I remember the subject here again. So I assume you have no more arguments and wish you a pleasant day.

TheDutchOven
11 months ago

Come on. How old are you? Probably you could be my grandson from age.

tommgrinn
11 months ago

How old are you?

You can always see when the arguments start. Because then you change more and more into the insulting mode.

TheDutchOven
11 months ago

How old are you?

tommgrinn
11 months ago

You know exactly what I mean.

Not really yet, but slowly I realize where you want to split the hair.

You just throw into the room, Moll is better without explaining that.

The answer is always the question. Maybe it’ll be clearer for you.

You could have just said you liked Moll.

Yes I could have made a right sentence – I was too lazy for it AND then I would have a strange discussion less. I think that was worth writing, right?

TheDutchOven
11 months ago

You know exactly what I mean. You just throw into the room, Moll is better without explaining that. You could have just said you liked Moll.