Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
27 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Paejexa
2 years ago

If I bought a monthly ticket here, I’d be over with about 80-100€.

However, I already pay about €60 per month to FTC insurance, plus fuel costs: 50 km per day, some 22 are 1100 km per month. At an average of about 7 liters per 100 km, the 70 liters would be, i.e. €119. If I’m expecting 40€ per month for the inspection, I’ll get a total of about 221€ for the car compared to a maximum of 100€ on the train. Advantage Monthly card: I can drive around all traffic connections, I would have additional costs in the car.

The car is only worth more if you really have only a few kilometers to work (up to 5 I would say now), or the ÖPNV is virtually not existent. I’m still privileged in my little place.

DodgeRT
2 years ago

It depends on how much you drive. With me the car is currently cheaper (of maintenance)

tinalisatina
2 years ago

You can’t say that at all. Depends on where you drive when you drive, how many people drive, whether you need a car anyway…

moreblack
2 years ago

I’ll take an old pendulum line from me as an example:

ICE month card €273. Total shuttle bus and train lasted approx. 1:45h when well ran, of which 1h in ICE where you sleep or Working could.

Car: ride takes without traffic ca. 1 hour, almost twice as fast, you can’t do anything about it.

Costsdistance 95km. Consumption about 7 liters/100km. I’ll take the “normal” gasoline prices of 1,50€/liter. Cost per month: 95 km*2 * 22 working days per month = 4180 km. Consumption 4180*7/100 = 292,6l. Costs 292,6l*1,50€=438,90€ gasoline costs per month. Then 200€ liability per year, 80€ tax, loss of value for used car approx. 800€ a year. So we are about again. 100€ on top per month. Maintenance and repairs are also on top.

–> Car costs twice as much as rail in the case. At 2.20€ gasoline price, logically even more.

ronnyarmin
2 years ago

Since there is neither THE ticket nor THE maintenance costs for a car, this general question cannot be answered. On the specific route you can calculate the costs on the basis of the cost of your car yourself.

manfredkock
2 years ago

Our car costs over 1000€ insurance per year. In addition, every two years of service and TÜF , and fuelling of diesel every 14 days. Driving by public transport is considerably cheaper. We got our car off.

LG by Manfred

goodquestion938
2 years ago

Nothing from both.

Car costs fuel, maintenance, insurance

Train has to be close to the railway station, otherwise bus or so must be expected.

car is flexible

Morchelmeister
2 years ago

At our Öffi prices here the car is cheaper. Even at a discount price of €2.10, the train would be more than €20 more expensive if I only take into account the working path.

All in all, rail would be cheaper, but then I could go shopping with the Boller car 😆.

Sophonisbe
2 years ago

Here clearly the track:

Railway:

  • Monthly ticket: 100 Euro/month

Car:

  • Purchase costs
  • Maintenance costs
  • Insurance costs
  • KFZ control
  • Sprit costs (35 km easy route)
OnePerson19
2 years ago

Always depends on the individual case.

In addition, time is money

MacMadB
2 years ago

Invoicing full costs.

Lupulus
2 years ago

This may surprise you, but:

It depends.

Jack334
2 years ago

Bin soldier and drive for free train ..from therefore 😂😂

Rheinflip
2 years ago

In order to get to the car at all, you have to invest several 1000 €.

SirAndiusNr2
2 years ago

Depends on the exact circumstances. The train is unfortunately very expensive. A small ecar you can drive with the AM driving licence can be cheaper.

lesterb42
2 years ago
Reply to  SirAndiusNr2

Never.

SirAndiusNr2
2 years ago
Reply to  lesterb42

Health?

SirAndiusNr2
2 years ago

It really depends on the exact circumstances. If I would work 30 kilometers further, then one per direction costs me approx. 18 euros.

There is no monthly ticket from the Transport Federation.

Or I’ll buy a monthly ticket for more than 100 euros and 2 extra tickets every day.

Or a railway card 50.

Now you have to figure out how much it costs.

Over 8 years, could actually become a zero sum game from it. Or sacrifice some more money, and enjoy the “comfort”

lesterb42
2 years ago

The car is never cheaper. The loss of value and repairs are missing in most comparison invoices.

SirAndiusNr2
2 years ago

Yeah. What’s with no one?

lesterb42
2 years ago

Right, there’s a greater danger in the train.

Heiko82937483
2 years ago

Definitely train.

What the car costs me to service and maintenance alone, help

TheAmigos
2 years ago

Of course the train

Teddy42
2 years ago

Have a company car at the 0 fare – company overnimt 100% of the cost.

Fantastische
2 years ago

E-car

lesterb42
2 years ago
Reply to  Fantastische

A retribution without the significant loss of value.

xyz911
2 years ago
Reply to  lesterb42

As well as maintenance and full-cassing expenses that do not fall away with new (electro) cars