Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
14 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
MeinName927
1 year ago

Russia has had the experience.

This sentence we by a German native speaker with quite probability than at least expressed.

Why? Experience is something abstract complex that you have in mind for a very long time. It’s nothing you have, and after a year it’s forgotten again. Then it would be just a snapshot of the sensation and not a real experience you have made.

Herons1001
1 year ago

Both sentences are grammatically correct, but the first set “Russia has made the experience” sounds more natural and is used more frequently.

xxXScarfaceXxx
1 year ago

Both, it comes to the context, because the formulations express different things and not the same.

JMC01
1 year ago

Depends on the context. Of course, the former is more common, if the sentence goes on, so

“Russia has made the experience that ….”

spanferkel14
1 year ago
Reply to  JMC01

So do I. I would only accept “experiences” as definitive justification and determination, e.g. in:

“Please let the Chef/Master/Captain decide. He has the (corresponding) experience. ‘

MaxMusterman353
1 year ago
Reply to  spanferkel14

Hey!

In the case of “doing experience” the emphasis lies on the action/the event, while in the case of “experience” the emphasis lies on the experience as a result. In the case of explanations and representations of the experience and processes, as indicated here, “making” helps.

So also the difference between “make” and “have”.

This is objective explanation. :

MaxMusterman353
1 year ago

Yeah, all right!

spanferkel14
1 year ago

Yeah, you’re right. Here is the point: .

Do I have to do another after the point?😂

“Prep. + battery” is not a set. This is not an answer to the question “Where (…)?”, just a note on grammar.

MaxMusterman353
1 year ago

Children like you.

I don’t have the three seconds. 😜

If you take the grammar so accurately:

The emphasis is ontheAction. Question:Wherelies x? + Dativ

There’s no point. A grammatically correct set is terminated at least with one point. You can do that if you explain something to others, don’t you? 😜

spanferkel14
1 year ago

Bullshit. You should already invest the three seconds in order to surpass the sentence and to eliminate grammatical errors, especially if you think you need to explain to another how the language works.

I’m annoying again. You don’t know the saying, “Who doesn’t need to use it, doesn’t need to use it at all”? We always heard that when we had to forget that. ðŸĪŠ

MaxMusterman353
1 year ago

I know that sounds weird. If you write quickly, you can’t pay attention to everything. Then you don’t need to bother. In common:

spanferkel14
1 year ago

Yes, all clear, E. make = action –> E. have = result.

The emphasis is on the Action. Question: Where lies x? + Dativ

  • I’m lying on the lazy skin.
  • I’m lying next to myem Man under ourhe Cuddly blanket im 🛌.
  • I’m lying in the 🛁.
MaxMusterman353
1 year ago

Hello!

“Russia has made the experience” is often used to point out a particular action or event, while “Russia has had the experience” places more focus on the state resulting from this experience.

In many cases, the two formulations are interchangeable, but there could be situations in which a formulation appears more natural or more suitable, depending on what should be emphasised. ECT

Correct are both.

Best regards from Maxime! 😊

Justme675
1 year ago

Russia has made the experience