Powerline in der Wohnung?
Ich habe es bereits mit Mesh-Repeatern versucht. Diese haben zwar eine etwas stabilere Verbindung gezeigt, jedoch treten manchmal immer noch Probleme auf, die beim Online-Surfen nervig sind. Das Problem ist, dass mein Zimmer, in dem sich mein PC befindet, sehr weit vom Router entfernt ist, der sich im Wohnzimmer befindet. Dort habe ich ungefähr 180 MBit, aber in meinem Zimmer mit dem Mesh-System sind es nur noch 20-30 MBit. Wäre eine Powerline-Lösung hilfreich? Ich kann keine LAN-Kabel vom Wohnzimmer bis zu meinem Zimmer verlegen, deshalb denke ich über Powerline nach.
(1 votes)
Loading...
Powerline can work very well, but it always depends on the power wiring and any line disruptors. With me it always worked satisfactorily, apparently not at Apollo. 😉
The best is therefore to try out, buy a set and test it.
But maybe you just placed your mesh reps wrong and they didn’t bring anything? Ideal would be a placement on halfway with a free view (no metal or thick walls in between) on router and computer.
With Powerline you use cables that have never been provided, manufactured and calibrated for data transmission.
It really can’t tell you if and how well it works.
No one can tell you if it works well, whether that will be permanent.
No matter how you turn it and turn it:
If you want stable and performant performance, you won’t get around Twisted-Pair cable or fiber optic cable.
With mesh over WLAN (i.e. without cable) the bandwidth is halved every time. It’s the worst thing you can do.
Powerline is the second best. As long as you’ve got one thing, it’s okay. However, Powerline interferes with your VDSL, so plug the router after the powerline adapter! If you have a detached house and more fases (current) you can forget it. If you live in the housing block, you have to think of your neighbors who also hang on the power grid. It can work, but it doesn’t have to.
Powerline adapters also crash regularly. Once a month you will have to restart all adapters.
that the bandwidth was halved earlier with the repeaters with WDS, with today’s Mesh Repeater this is no longer so. Therefore, a reasonably built mesh system is much better than Powerline. Of course, a mesh system is where the repeaters are connected to the router via cable, better, but directly to use Lankabel is of course always the best option.
A mesh repeater connected via WLAN must send and receive! So he has to do twice. Although it can use different frequencies, as it does professional devices, it does not make Fritzbox. Professional devices make mesh over the 5 GHz band and access via the 2 GHz band.
And don’t start with Multi-Mimo. Mimo means he can help more clients simultaneously. More, not one.
I can’t understand the problems you’re facing at Powerline despite years of use. My devolos have not even crashed for years, despite EFH with several phases, my connection values were i.O. clear, far from the imagination specifications on the packaging, but good to use (depending on the distance between 200 and 500 MBit). However, it is actually a lucky game.
Two devices are still running quite well. But if it’s three or four, I’ve always got problems. It also depends on whether consumers are approaching. My well pump was so upset. A lawn mower, too. I think everything with 2 KW is unfavourable.
yes, the 3 Gbit are actually the bundled value displayed in the mesh overview. However, I have different SSIDs for 2.4 and 5 Ghz. that devices nciht unintentionally select into the slow 2.4 Ghz network. I only work with 5 Ghz. And yes, it goes through a concrete wall. It shouldn’t be more than one.
WPS is only uncertain as long as it is active. It allows exactly 1 registration if this happens, although the desired device is not yet online, you can see foreign devices in the FB and throw them out and change the WLAN password. Never happened to me.
It is a Fritzbox 6690 cable.
What do you have for a Fritzbox? Do you have Wifi6 in operation? However, the 3000AX can only have a maximum of 2400 MBit/s in the Wifi 6. You have to connect all bands (2,4, 5, and 6) and also bundle all channels. On the one hand, there are problems with the neighbors and on the other, as you want to get through concrete walls with 5 GHz, I’m a mystery. Chipboard walls or plasterboard goes like this, but no concrete. And with reinforced concrete, it’s already after 50 cm.
And watch: setup is done by WPS. The WPS is extremely uncertain, you know, right?
the repeaters should be set up where they still get a reasonable signal. My AVM Fritz!Repeater 3000AX is still connected to the FB with 3.1 Gbits and I get even more easily 600-700 Mbit real data rate 2 rooms. Without the repeater it is more like ~100 Mbit
Okay, I had a 3some comedy, there were never any problems. If, of course, disturbers are on the net, the connection will break up. But my devolos never hung up.
Okay, that was new with the new Fritzkists. I have only Ubiquiti privately and on work HP and Cisco.
However, in order to get to 1300 MBIt/s throughput, no wall or even several walls may be in between. You have that if you want to do Mesh in the house. After all, you want to go where you don’t even come. So you set the first “repeater” about in the middle. Maybe you have 400 Mbit. And you have to remember your neighbors. They will also have Wi-Fi and have a few channels. That you can use everything for yourself alone will never be the case. At least not in a multi-family house. In a detached house, I would pull cables anyway. And then… don’t try to go to 5 G. That’s hardly going through concrete walls. At least it’s not going through my ceiling so I had to set up 1 AccessPoint per floor. Connected by cable, of course. And by PoE. Then it works with the roaming.
That’s wrong.
Good luck!
the question is more, what do you have for a router, and for Mesh Repeater and how have you positioned and configured it.
If the signal is weak in your room, it doesn’t help to add a mesh repeater there. It must be positioned at a point where it still receives at least 50% signal strength from the router, then it can increase the range.
Powerline is a good thing, can work or not. It is quite susceptible to interference and can also interfere with other devices up to the DSL connection.
FRITZ!Box and several mesh repeaters in different rooms
what repeater and what Fritzbox exactly?
Powerline CAN work, but don’t do it.
This ultimately depends on the house installation and the age of the electrical lines. Also, poorly undisturbed electrical appliances are sufficient to hinder or completely interrupt the connection.
And if it’s stupid, you can also have phase couplers installed in the counter box by electricians so that even a connection works.
Powerline is worth considering in new buildings, otherwise no replacement for network cables.
So you mean a D-Lan? Absolutely!
My bedroom is also one floor taller and there’s only a little bit to nothing at all. That’s why I also picked up Fritz’s DLAN repeater, where you plug the device into a socket near the router, LAN cable in and the counterpart in my bedroom converts it into my WLAN.
The only thing you need to make sure that both sockets are in the same “power circuit”. At least that’s how my acquaintance explained it’s the electrician. Makes sense.