Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
13 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
spanferkel14
1 year ago

Purely grammatically, the state passiv is necessary, i.e. a shop, museum, restaurant etc. opened or closed

  • The supermarket XXX the every morning at 7:00 open / open.
  • Then is from 7:00 to 22:00 for customers on / open / open.
  • At 22:00 the the supermarket closed.
  • He is then from 22:00 to 7:00 to / closed.

But, by way of language, it is said that there are shops, shopping centers, all kinds of gastronomic establishments, workshops, cultural institutions (museums, exhibitions etc.) and offices, in fact, wherever a person can get rid of his money, ask for information etc., also:

  • The workshop, the museum, the TÜV, the shop, the tax office, the swimming pool etc. opens / closes at…
  • The workshop etc. has from … to … Clock open / open / closed / closed.
WilliamDeWorde
1 year ago

I would say: is open or has opened, and it should be noted that by daily use the meaning of “opened” has changed.

You could also say: The store has been opened, now it is open.

Desparativum
1 year ago

A shop can open they were (cf.: “)is“) and someone can open something, for example a door they have (cf.: “)has“).

Simbacherin1
1 year ago

The bakery is open.

= The bakery has opened.

At least in Bavaria this means the same thing.

spanferkel14
1 year ago
Reply to  Simbacherin1

In Prussia also 😉

Elias5385
1 year ago

You can use both in different things, for example. The door is open. Right. The store opened.

user824221
1 year ago

depends on xd

DerKalif
1 year ago

There are both.

  • … is open… – It’s a copula or passive set. (Come to the linguistic school, how to interpret the sentence.)
  • … has opened… – Is a set in preteriority in active.
spanferkel14
1 year ago
Reply to  DerKalif

“Hat opened” is not a preterior activity.

DerKalif
1 year ago
Reply to  spanferkel14

You caught me… I didn’t pay attention! Sorry to the FS.

DerKalif
1 year ago

Very good, I’m not even a scout…

spanferkel14
1 year ago

Don’t worry. 🤗 Your little mistake made me insert the active process of opening (in the present) into my post. So you did a good job.

Pfiati
1 year ago

Open it. 😉