Gitarre und Altsaxophon Tonhöhenunterschied?
Ich spiele Gitarre und mein Bruder Saxophon. Wir wollten ein Stück zusammenspielen und dabei habe ich festgestellt, dass die Töne völlig verschieden sind, und ich meine nicht in verschiedenen Oktaven. Sein C zum Beispiel klingt bei mir wie ein E. Habe ich irgendwas übersehen? Wir beide benutzen ja den gleichen Notenschlüssel.
The old saxophone is called Es-Altsaxofon. The C he played is sounding an es. Therefore, an es-altsaxofon in the orchestra also has an es-voices. Of course, by the other tones also in a different tone. When the piano plays C major (no sign), the Alt-Sax A major (3# more) has piano B major Alt-Sax G major. Alt-Sax always has 3# more or 3b less.
What kind of saxophone do you have?
There are B- and Es-Saxophones (if I get this so completely right behind…). This is the “basic tone”. If the guitar is completely “normal” (with tuning fork or tuning fork e.g.), then you have to be able to transpose a bit before the interplay works.
Nonetheless, a C is and remains a C. No matter what instrument it is played, no matter in which key the piece is listed.
Yeah, or just not… if I play the basic tone on my trumpet, that’s “sounding” a B, though it’s a C after my notes…
he has an es-saxophone
Okay, then he has to transpose.
That means the Grundton is an Es. If he plays for C notes and the written C is an It, then there are two possibilities: to change the guitar accordingly, to transpose on the clarinet, or to transpose with the guitar. The simplest should be the tuning of the guitar, so that from the C there becomes an esteem. Then you don’t have to learn so much new, and the handles aren’t so complicated…
Thanks for the help! I have the capo in the 3rd. Bundle clamped and now it sounds the same.
I have such a thing, but I only use it very rarely to control the neck curvatures of my guitars. I haven’t played it yet, I think. Can’t remember… 🤣
Right. Since I’ve never had a Kapo, I just didn’t have the idea.
Of course you can tune the guitar, but I wouldn’t like to vote my guitars a third higher. The elevated string has an effect on the string position, so it might be a better idea to grab a capodaster.
The tones are clearly defined, they refer to the chamber tone A (normally 440 Hz). Thus, a C on each instrument is a C and it sounds like a C. Whatever, but one of you makes something basically wrong.
but why do they sound different?
Take a chromatic tuning device and play the C on your guitar. Then you see if you really play a C. Then let your brother comfort the C on his horn and see if he really comforts a C.
Depends on what you learned in saxophone games: I play trumpet. that is a B-instrument…
Then he must transpose.
Thanks for the help! I have the capo in the 3rd. Bundle clamped and now it sounds the same.
Basstom has probably never played in the orchestra. He has no idea
I wrote…
And actually, I’ve never had to play with winds. That was never in my interest.
But what about you, wanting stress, or how should I interpret your statement?
In practice, a capodaster is used in guitars rather than inappropriate.
I’m telling you all the time… It’s easier to change the guitar…
I have just overlooked the need to transpose the saxophone.
they just tried. If I play a C, something between d and e sounds with him. I mean, he’s not doing anything wrong, that’s what his teacher told him. Just don’t understand why this is so