Is there a rule for this?

2. Out of caution, he took a different route.

I don't understand the combination of "one" and the article "other".

So, I understand that it's in the accusative case. But what rule allows it to be written like that? One way and the other.

(No Ratings Yet)
Loading...

Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
6 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
DerKalif
10 months ago

You mean because Other often counted to the (indefinite) pronouns and therefore could actually take over the position of the article or should not be like an adjective between article and noun?

I honestly never thought about it – and I didn’t notice it until your question… I can only answer you from the stand:

There are always cases in languages in general and word types in particular that are more prototypical for something than others; So there are quite cases where something can be untypical, just like here. Ander… seems to be somewhere between pronouns and adjectives, so has characteristics of both.

Generally speaking languages/grams are not black and white; there will always be grayscales. Even if people who, for example, call at language counselling points who never want to hear how the experience shows. 😀

Schillerxoxo
10 months ago

“One” is an indefinite article, and “other” is an adjective.

Think like Schiller and you’ll understand.

spanferkel14
9 months ago

In German there are 3 adjectives that you have to learn as a foreigner. As a native speaker, you usually do that automatically, unless you have grown up in an environment where people (parents, friends, etc.) do not speak correctly.

  • Adjective according to certain article, e.g. the othere Wine
  • Adjective according to indefinite article, e.g. anotherhe Wine
  • Adjective to zero article, e.g.he Wine

Here is the table, please click to enlarge:

OlliBjoern
10 months ago

Nominative: another way (like “a big dog”)

Rechargeable: one-en another way (like “a big dog”)

In the battery, both the indefinite article gets the ending (in the case of masculine subjects, i.e. the path, the dog,…) and the adjective (big > large, ander(e) > others).

I see a big dog.

He’s going another way.

Schemset
10 months ago

“other” is an adjective, “a” of the articles.

You can say:

“He took a way” – “a” is an indefinite article.

And then an adjective is added to the “path”, which describes the way more precisely: the path is “other”.

Other example:

“He took the narrow way” – that would be the same constellation, but with certain article.

LastDayofEden
10 months ago

You can replace “other” with other (😅) adjectives, then it might make sense again:

– “a beautiful path”

– “a faster way”

– “a new way”

Are you okay?