Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
10 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kajjo
2 months ago

The question would be: Whose apple is that?

The question is correct. Not all questions with the genitive question word “wessen” give answer with a genitive. This is a bit confusing in German.

Above all, consider one:

Ownership (“Possessiv”) can be expressed by both Kasus (Genitiv), by prepositions (“from me”) and by pronouns (“my, your”).

The genitive is even more rare. You can answer a variety of questions:

  • This is my apple.
  • The apple is mine.
  • This is Peter’s apple.
  • This is Peter’s apple.

This is my apple.

This statement has nothing to do with a possible question, but stands for itself.

It’s a classic predicative set. “That” and “my apple” are both nominatives. Also compare sentences like “I’m a good pilot.” or “She’ll be a doctor.”

upbrunce
2 months ago

The question is “who or what”, you ask here for the predictive, which determines the demonstrative pronoun and at the same time subject “Das” (deictically and adjectively). It’s in the nominative: my apple. If you ask the question “wessen” you ask for the Genitivattribute, the answer would be “My”.

lg up

MinusDrei651
2 months ago

Hello TeclaG

Whose? Genetic

Whose apple is that?

LG

Kajjo
2 months ago
Reply to  MinusDrei651

This is mine.

Also here is “my” Nominativ Singular, strongly declinated, reference to apple.

MinusDrei651
2 months ago
Reply to  Kajjo

was rather intuitive.. hmm.. does not give an exception to any rule – terrible sometimes the German language – has for all the rules but no one holds

Can you give me another sentence with my nominative singing?

MinusDrei651
2 months ago
Reply to  Kajjo

Upbrunce has a statement 🙂

Kajjo
2 months ago

“Sei” or “is” makes no difference. Both are precedent sets with the predictive in the nominative (congruent to the subject).

The strong declination in these sentences makes it even more confusing, but it doesn’t change anything in the simple predicative.

That’s mine.

That’s mine. (my apple)

That’s mine. (my child)

MinusDrei651
2 months ago

How about the answer “he is mine” for the apple?

A clear masculine that refers to the apple but not that of my

Kajjo
2 months ago

Mine is bigger.

As an example. .