Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
13 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
MinusDrei651
5 months ago

Hello dogmatist

It’s all right, but not everything.

Am and the have not been

“At the beginning of next year”

Beginning (which beginning? – the, of the year) it is already defined by the sentence – so you can drop the article and the preposition: falls “on the” (am).

Beginning of the year

From the (vom) Dativ; of (vom) Genitiv

Then we are with:

Beginning of the year

Whose year? Next!

So also the year is defined and therefore does not need an article.

Beginning next year 🙂

LG

Mauritan
5 months ago

I think everything is right.

Spaniards, why do you think that

At the beginning of next year

was wrong?

It is the short form for At the beginning of next year. Well, it’s not nice and “cross” too, because there’s no article about logic and language.

But the grammar? I think it’s right.

Mauritan
5 months ago
Reply to  Dogmatist

This is more a feeling than mathematical logic. It’s too many concretizations. We use an article when it becomes concrete. So not “a” child, but “the” child. So a certain one.

If you say “next” year, it’s clear that it’s 2025. At first, what it means is also scheduled. Now before “beginning” also put an article to “dedicate” it is too many “Lärm”.

“At the beginning of next year” seems to me sufficiently precise. Therefore, I felt a further reinforcement as transverse. It’s a matter of taste.

HabSowiesoRecht
5 months ago

“At the beginning of next year” is wrong, the rest is right.

MaxMusterman353
5 months ago

Why?

HabSowiesoRecht
5 months ago

Because the Duden says so.

MaxMusterman353
5 months ago

Finally, this is not about mere nominalphrases as in I am school, right? 🤣

MaxMusterman353
5 months ago

Because the Duden says so.

Where?

HabSowiesoRecht
5 months ago

I’m sorry, but I’m not going into such questions. “I am school” <- what is wrong? If you find out, you already have your answer.

MaxMusterman353
5 months ago

Applause!

HabSowiesoRecht
5 months ago

duden.de

MaxMusterman353
5 months ago

Really? Can you send me the page?