Do you have to know the periodic table by heart?

Over the holidays, our chemistry teacher gave us the task of memorizing the first 20 elements of the periodic table, including atomic numbers and such. Is that normal? It seems completely unnecessary to me; most people are given that in homework, right?

(4 votes)
Loading...

Similar Posts

Subscribe
Notify of
19 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
RedPanther
1 year ago

There is a difference between the whole PSE to learn by heart or only first 20 elements to learn.

Nobody learns the whole PSE. Even in a chemistry study, some elements are so rare that they can be checked as needed. The 40-50 elements, which one needs to be regularly, loop in memory.

But the elements with which the basic principles of chemistry are explained in chemistry classes are now roughly the first 20.

And now it is essential to have certain basics in mind. If the chemistry teacher declares that this and that element reacts so and so because of its position in the PSE, then one should know this position as a listener in order to understand the explanation. Otherwise, you have the choice of whether you want to go after and stop listening, or whether you simply don’t get what it is about.

Now we all know how to tick as a student. What do you think, how many pupils remember the most important elements when the teacher says that this is sensible?

If he gives it as an explicit task, he may at least pretend that the students have learned it. And can accordingly make meaningful lessons instead of starting with Adam & Eva at every single explanation.

So yes, it’s normal.

And yes, it is also normal to presume in exams that pupils know “the usual suspects” and do not need any reference.

Bergliebhaberin
1 year ago

Hey!

Yeah, we have to. At least if you choose the scientific branch, you have to. I don’t know how it is. I think we have to learn something by heart, but I do.

So yes, that’s normal, and you can also ask about the vacation.

Love

verreisterNutzer
1 year ago

We didn’t have to, deep in the last millennium. And in retrospect, I have to say that we probably would have strangled our teacher if he had asked for such a thing…

milujijazyky
1 year ago

It is good if it is not necessary to check for every pup during chemical calculation or determination of the molar mass. 20 learning element is not a thing. One more help: in this area of the PSE, most rounded atomic masses are double the order number. Exceptions: H = 1, then boron, phosphorus, chlorine, argon and potassium.

spelman
1 year ago

No, we didn’t have to. The boardwork was allowed to be used in all scientific subjects, and the period system stood directly in the book cover.

LuciusArtorius
1 year ago

So we had to be able to dig it out.

Herfried1973
1 year ago

Yeah is normal.

Munga01
1 year ago

My school time has been very long and yes, we had to learn it by heart.

verreisterNutzer
1 year ago
Reply to  Munga01

When did you go to school and where?

Munga01
1 year ago

I was trained in Hesse in 1967.

Munga01
1 year ago

Yeah, sure.

verreisterNutzer
1 year ago

Then you remember what a dial phone is.

STURMT1G3R
1 year ago

No, what? It’s in the boardwork.

Tannibi
1 year ago
Reply to  STURMT1G3R

Everything you learn at school is in some tablework.

STURMT1G3R
1 year ago
Reply to  Tannibi

Why do you have to make another tea bag?

RedPanther
1 year ago
Reply to  STURMT1G3R

It’s in the boardwork.

  1. You always have a boardwork available? So, for example, if you’re standing in the lab before an experimental setup and considering what could go wrong?
  2. Things spontaneously knowing, instead of having to look at them in the boardwork, at least saves time. I remember a module check in BWL, where everyone is happy that they are open book, some dragged whole boxes of paper to their place, and then there were so many tasks that you were not finished at the best will, even if you had to check only half of the answers.
STURMT1G3R
1 year ago
Reply to  RedPanther

One more with speech needs. It’s about the period system. Congratulations, if you are able to remember the essential things.

For example, I never have a spit in school – because I never needed it – I’m so crassed.

Tannibi
1 year ago

Did I? I don’t even know what it means.
Hopefully it doesn’t have to be
by my commentary to the psychologist for three years.

Tannibi
1 year ago

Sounds pretty stupid.