Subscribe
Notify of
24 Answers
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
spanferkel14
1 year ago

The sentence is doubled.

  • Either: In my opinion his arguments are very convincing.
  • Or: I think that his arguments are very convincing.
  • Or: I think his arguments are very convincing.
  • Or: I think/find that his arguments are very convincing.
  • Or: I think his arguments are very convincing.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

  • After my opinion/view/record … (by + dative)
  • My opinion/view/record After … (Dative + after; slightly more elegant)

but:

  • I am the opinion/view/record that … (genitive)
  • I am the same opinion/view/record as you. (genitive)
  • I am your opinion/view/record. (genitive)
Konstantin51382
1 year ago
Reply to  spanferkel14

Hello spanferkel14, I would be very pleased if you could answer my latest question about the word "cheap"; with regard to the topic "word meaning", you have the most idea. For example, I found your explanation of the word "poor" very understandable.

spanferkel14
1 year ago
Reply to  spanferkel14

๐ŸŒฟ๐ŸŒทThank you for your star! ๐ŸŒบ๐Ÿƒ

iqKleinerDrache
1 year ago

Dativus judicantis

This dative refers to the position from which a statement is valid.

is all that for Latin, I wasn't so bad in these things… only the terms are Latin and not everyday language

In German, it would have to be called "Geber Fall". Why not?

How about it

1.Case: Nominative = Name

2.Call: Genetic = Origin

3.case: Dative = donor

Case 4: Battery = Reason

It is also better to see that genitive, the dative is formulated in reverse. The donor gives something. Something of the donor.

gufrastella
1 year ago

Hello maxmuste121123!

"In my opinion, his arguments are very convincing?"

The formulations with the preposition After , less often also according to, according to, thanks are formed with the Dativ.

Since the Dativ at Feminina is the same as the genitive, it won't be clear.

Nominative the opinion,

Genetic the opinion,

Dative the opinion,

Accurate the opinion.

If you take a masculine, it becomes clear:

Nominative the reason,

Genetic the reason,

Dative the reason,

Accurate the reason

The After, my Feeling for – Dative

With genitive is eg mine it reveals s.

LG

gufrastella

Koschutnig
1 year ago
Reply to  maxmuste121123

There is apparently a movement to counteract the genitive death by the dative ("the dative is his death", onion fish) by incorrect new genitive instead of the correct dative.

gufrastella
1 year ago
Reply to  maxmuste121123

Yeah, here's the dative forms right.

gufrastella
1 year ago

Why?

Ghostwriter2
1 year ago

The preposition After (even if it is in post position) is connected to the tripod, eg according to my knowledge ( not : according to my knowledge).

Konstantin51382
1 year ago
Reply to  Ghostwriter2

Ah, right and expressions, as I think, are in the genitive and therefore without preposition.

martrud
1 year ago

Only one language comment:

"Genitive" (etymologically) has more to do with "genital" than with "Geneva".

latricolore, UserMod Light

You can try to replace the female noun with a male or causal, then it becomes clear:

After my understanding

Apart from that, After to the prepositions that always demand dative .

In my opinion and I think are by the way double-moppelt = no beautiful German.

My opinion his arguments are very convincing.

I find his arguments very convincing.

Katarasami
1 year ago

Whose opinion?

In my opinion. So genitive.

But the sentence itself is weird. I would have said I find his arguments very convincing.

Koschutnig
1 year ago
Reply to  Katarasami

You're on the wrong track, because you're asking for the meaning of the pronoun. Just take it " Opinion" a word that is not a feminine, eg "d : Knowledge or " of faith ", then you realize that the preposition After as a "post position" Dative rules: mine m Knowledge After / my m Believe.

But you ask " whose opinion?" after belonging by the pronoun. The question is possible in all 4 cases and the answer is the same:

N: my opinion is…

G: my r For the opinion

D: mine r Opinion After

A: my opinion

Katarasami
1 year ago
Reply to  Koschutnig

Look at what others write. Everyone says it's genitive. So it's more likely that we're right than you're right.

Koschutnig
1 year ago

What? Please, be so good and look not only, but also LIES what All others have written! No one except Constantine says the genitive After be right! Everyone says it's Dative!

Again for you: With the question whose n? for Opinion you just get the difference. my/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/her/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/hi s/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his/his etc. and in any case. For After On the other hand, the dative is always standing before or after!

Konstantin51382
1 year ago

In genitive: someone's opinion

The friend of Mother = Whose friend? So genitive, only to illustrate this, since it is also " of in your example.

At least I think so.

Ghostwriter2
1 year ago

Clicking on "helpful" was a mistake!

Tannibi
1 year ago

Dative, because it's called "bye".

"In my opinion, I think…" sounds strange.

Ghostwriter2
1 year ago
Reply to  Tannibi

"In my opinion, I think…" sounds strange.

Right!

Konstantin51382
1 year ago
Reply to  Ghostwriter2

Pleonasm because both expresses their own view, with a pleonasm being correct and the phrase of the questioner being wrong?

Ghostwriter2
1 year ago

Yeah.